# New York New York Sandwiches

**Sandwich Shop** - Palo Alto

Google: 4.3/5 (239 reviews)

## A Fresh, Made-From-Scratch Sandwich That Feels Like Home

You're not just grabbing a quick bite — you're sitting down to something made right in front of you, with care, by someone who's been doing this for 18 years.

## Why customers choose us

### Fresh-Made Food You Can Trust
Customers hire New York New York Sandwiches when they want food prepared right in front of them, not pulled from a warmer. The made-to-order process delivers a home-cooked quality that pre-made alternatives simply cannot replicate.
> "What I loved about the bagel egg sandwich I had is egg was prepared fresh after I ordered. The taste was exquisite. You will feel as if you are eating at home."

### A Genuine, Personal Experience
Customers choose this shop when they want a human connection behind their meal — not a transactional fast-food exchange. The owner's 18 years of presence creates a sense of warmth and craft that keeps people coming back.
> "Sandwhiches made from scratch right in front of you, and the sweetest shop owner who has been here for 18 years! This place is a gem and a true hole in the wall."

### A Satisfying Classic Sandwich
When people crave a specific, well-executed sandwich — like a Reuben done the New York way — this is the place they hire. The focused menu and consistent execution deliver on that craving reliably.
> "I ordered a "Grilled NY Famous Reuben with Sauerkraut & 1000 Island Dressing", OMG, it's just so good for the summer."

## What customers praise

- **Eggs cooked fresh to order** - "What I loved about the bagel egg sandwich I had is egg was prepared fresh after I ordered."
- **Sandwiches made from scratch in front of you** - "Sandwhiches made from scratch right in front of you"
- **The Grilled NY Reuben with Sauerkraut & 1000 Island Dressing** - "I ordered a "Grilled NY Famous Reuben with Sauerkraut & 1000 Island Dressing", OMG, it's just so good for the summer."
- **The bagel sandwich** - "The bagel was delicious."
- **Owner with 18 years at the shop** - "the sweetest shop owner who has been here for 18 years!"
- **A sandwich made with care and attention** - "A sandwich made with love."
- **Feels like a home-cooked meal** - "You will feel as if you are eating at home."
- **A tucked-away location worth seeking out** - "A hidden gem in Palo Alto, you have to come all the way to the end of street, but totally worth it."

## Special touches

- **Made fresh to order, right in front of you**: Every sandwich is prepared from scratch after you place your order — you can watch it come together in real time, so you know exactly what's going into your food.
- **Eggs cooked fresh, not pre-made**: Egg sandwiches aren't sitting under a heat lamp. The egg is cracked and cooked only after you order, giving it a home-cooked quality that customers notice immediately.
- **An owner who has stayed for 18 years**: The same owner has been behind the counter for nearly two decades — a rare continuity that signals genuine commitment to the craft and the community.
- **A personal, human touch at the counter**: The owner cooks your sandwich himself, turning what could be a quick transaction into a small moment of connection with the person making your food.
- **Sandwiches made with visible care**: Customers consistently describe a quality that feels intentional rather than routine — the kind of attention that comes through in the finished product and is hard to fake at scale.
- **A tucked-away location that rewards the effort**: The shop sits at the end of a street, off the main path — which means the people who find it feel like they've discovered something worth sharing with others.
- **A warm, welcoming atmosphere**: Multiple customers independently highlight how warm and personable the owner is, creating a sense of being welcomed rather than just served.
- **A neighbourhood scale that feels intimate**: With only a handful of small tables, the space stays quiet and unhurried — closer to a neighbour's kitchen than a busy lunch counter.

## Tips for visitors

- 🗺️ **Find the End of the Street**: The shop is tucked away at the end of the street, so keep walking and trust that the journey is worth it.
- 🪑 **Expect a Cozy, Compact Space**: With only a few small tables inside, this is best treated as a quick stop or takeaway rather than a sit-down meal.
- 👀 **Watch Your Sandwich Being Made**: Everything is prepared fresh right in front of you after you order, so expect a short wait while your food is made to order.
- 🥚 **Try the Bagel Egg Sandwich**: Multiple reviewers highlight the bagel egg sandwich as a standout choice, with the egg cooked fresh after you place your order.
- 🥪 **Consider the Reuben**: The Grilled NY Famous Reuben with Sauerkraut and 1000 Island Dressing comes highly recommended as a satisfying, flavour-packed option.
- 😊 **Chat with the Owner**: The long-time owner is known for being warm and welcoming, so take a moment to say hello when you visit.

## Contact

Phone: (650) 328-6700

---
Source: https://favurl.com/new-york-sandwiches